Number 1 Pizza

Discover Number 1 Pizza in Lake George, NY – renowned for authentic NYC-style pizza, delicious cannoli, garlic knots, lasagna, meatballs, calzone, and more. Call +1 518-685-3424 for the best Italian flavors!

Welcome to Number 1 Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Number 1 Pizza
Number 1 Pizza
Number 1 Pizza
Number 1 Pizza

Number 1 Pizza invites you to savor the true taste of Italy right in the heart of Lake George. Located at 509 Canada St, this charming pizza restaurant boasts a welcoming atmosphere filled with the wafting aroma of freshly baked dough and zesty tomato sauce. Diners rave about the authentic NYC-style pizza crafted by a skilled chef renowned for their pizza and Italian specialties. Whether it’s a casual lunch or a cozy dinner, Number 1 Pizza subtly blends comfort and authenticity.

The restaurant features a cozy interior with a classic pizzeria vibe, where families gather to enjoy hearty meals.

From mouthwatering garlic knots to rich lasagna, there’s something for everyone. The lively atmosphere buzzes with laughter and the clinking of plates, making it a perfect spot to share good food among friends and family.

Location & Contact

Address

509 Canada St, Lake George, NY 12845, United States

Phone

+1 518-685-3424

Social Media

About

Number 1 Pizza
Number 1 Pizza
Number 1 Pizza
Number 1 Pizza

Number 1 Pizza stands out in the Lake George culinary scene for its dedication to quality Italian cuisine. With a sleek design, the restaurant is not just about aesthetics; it focuses on providing dishes that deliver authentic flavors. The family-operated business takes pride in maintaining a menu that reflects the best of Italy, serving everything from classic pizza to hearty pasta dishes. Their New York-style pizza impresses with its chewy crust and rich toppings, a true delight for pizza enthusiasts.

Every team member, from the kitchen staff to the servers, shares a passion for Italian cooking. The chef honed their skills in the vibrant streets of New York City, bringing an authentic twist to the small-town dining experience. With years of experience and a refined technique, patrons can expect dishes that are as delicious as they are visually appealing. The ingredients are sourced with intention, providing fresh produce and high-quality meats that enhance every meal.

Notably, Fridays and Saturdays are peak times, with the restaurant reaching full capacity, especially at 2 PM and 7 PM, respectively. To enjoy a quieter experience, it’s best to visit during the week, especially late on Tuesday or Wednesday evenings. Regulars and newcomers alike appreciate the straightforward yet extensive menu, featuring 13 delectable items that cater to all tastes.

From the robust flavors of their Antipasto Italian Best salad to the indulgent Eggplant Rollatini with pasta, every dish invites diners to discover culinary excellence. The family-friendly establishment embraces community spirit; you might even spot local teams engaging in spirited discussions over a pizza pie.

Work Hours

  • Sunday12-9 PM
  • Monday12-9 PM
  • Tuesday12-9 PM
  • Wednesday12-9 PM
  • Thursday12-9 PM
  • Friday12-9 PM
  • Saturday12-9 PM

Number 1 Pizza excels in delivering classic Italian dishes with a twist. Highlights include their Large Stuffed Shells with Meatballs, Spinach Ravioli alla Fiorentina with Mushroom, and Fettuccine Alfredo. Each dish reflects a love for traditional cooking, made with carefully sourced ingredients that ignite the palate.

The restaurant also features a selection of appetizers, such as delicious Garlic Bread, and the fan-favorite Cannoli for dessert.

With an average price of around $18.92 for a meal, diners experience value without sacrificing quality.

The ambiance plays a crucial role in Number 1 Pizza's charm. It not only serves as a dining destination but also as a community hub where locals often gather, making it a great place to meet friends or celebrate special occasions.

Number 1 Pizza

Number 1 Pizza greets visitors with a rustic exterior that embodies warmth and charm. Its inviting façade hints at the culinary adventure awaiting inside. The neat landscaping and exterior décor featuring pizza-themed art add to the restaurant’s overall appeal.

Surrounded by Lake George's natural beauty, diners can enjoy the vibrant atmosphere of the area, making it a perfect stop after a day of exploring. Outdoor seating becomes an extension of the lively vibes, offering a casual space to unwind with friends while savoring Italian delights.

Customer Reviews

Really good, classic pizza! My photo doesn't do it justice - it was even better than the picture! The people are extremely kind. The chef even wears the chef's hat! Can't go wrong with number 1 pizza! Crust is crispy and the cheese is nice and gooey :)

M
Melina C.

We were in town for a sporting event this weekend. Stopped there on the way by and grabbed some cannoli to go. They were excellent. We then decided to return for dinner and our pizza, bread knots and gnocchi were equally as good. The staff was very friendly, and their authenticity really sets them apart. They were so proud of their One Bite ranking of 7.9. We will make this a stop every time we are in town.

B
Britt A.

Great spot just off the main strip in Lake George. Like 100 yards off! Hard to walk bc no sidewalk but the drive is just seconds off the main strip. My father recommended it and it didn't disappoint! We went on a random Monday afternoon in August and were the only family there. Hard to judge ambience of a pizza shop on a Monday afternoon but the food was a HOME RUN as was the help. Caring and kind staff and absolutely phenomenal pizza, chicken tenders (not rubbery), Cajun fries, and the chicken Caesar salad was great too, as was the cannoli! Check it out. Recommend you get pizza here when you travel to Lake George! Greatest vacation spot. *UPDATE prices have become insane. $15.99 for 3 chicken tenders and a handful of French fries. Between that and selling cans of soda for $2-3...Not sure we'll return. Pizza is tho so it is what it is.

A
Adam S.

Almost ate a whole pie between 2 people as it was just so wonderful. The owners are such spectacular people and would come back just to see them alone!!

P
Pinky

I was traveling thru town and stopped here for pizza. Got a 12 inch with pepperoni, onion, and green peppers. The peppers are from a can and not cut fresh like the onions. Overall, the pizza is 3.5 out of 5. Asked for well done but got regular cooked. And i heard the lady tell the guys making my pizza that i wanted it well done, twice.I gave this 5 star because of the ladies working there tonight. They were awesome and gave me 4 piece garlic knots with dipping sauce for free.. It was $20 bucks. Might not be expensive around this area. Lake George, NY. Can't comment on other dishes or menu items. Keep up the good work, ladies. To the guy who made my pizza, you need to follow directions. I was there Saturday 22, 2024, at 8:10 pm.

P
Patrick H.

Wonderful place. Great pizza, and very friendly staff. My wife and I came here for a late lunch with our 7-year old and 2-year old, and the staff was so accommodating. The chef (possibly the owner, too?) came out with our pizza himself and was very kind to our family. We also ordered garlic knots, and they were the best we've ever had. It was nice to find a place that was away from the hustle and bustle of Lake George Village but still fairly close to everything.

T
Tim S.